View Single Post
Old 07-16-08, 04:14 PM   #22 (permalink)
St. Stalin the Apathetic
an apparition
 
St. Stalin the Apathetic's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 32,422
Quote:
Originally Posted by MicahB View Post
sounds like a hella slippery slope to me!
you eat mcdonalds, you get cancer, no halp for you!
you smoke tobacco, you get cancer, no halp for you!
you sit on a couch all day, get fat, get diabetes, no halp for you!
Here's the problem with your argument though.... cancer is a lot more difficult to trace to a source. Smoking, yeah. And think about what we've done with regard to gov't control on that issue. You want the same controls on gay sex? The requirement of condoms and the gov't will fine you if you don't and further... throw you in jail if you spread the disease?

Look, I'm not advocating his argument. I'm saying that when we can mitigate the harm from a risky behavior it makes it more likely that people will engage in the behavior - no more no less. You, for example, would be far more likely to jump out of an airplane with a parachute than without one. A cure for AIDs is a bit like a parachute

Quote:
Originally Posted by MicahB View Post
racist!
I'm black - how can that be
St. Stalin the Apathetic is online now   Reply With Quote